McMenamin helped Dromore win the Tyrone Senior Football Championship in 2007, beating Coalisland in the final.
This indiscipline was apparent throughout his career,[5][6] and he made a name for his verbal taunting of his direct opponents during matches as well,[7][8] which was mentioned by Oisín McConville in his autobiography.
This was upgraded to a sending off after the game, which meant that McMenamin would be suspended for the following four weeks,[10] but Tyrone launched an appeal, employing the services of former player, and practising solicitor, Feargal Logan.
[12] In the opening game of the 2007 Ulster Senior Football Championship, despite being one of the few first choice panellists available on the injury-hit side, he was substituted just before half time because he had already picked up a yellow card and a ticking—meaning he was one bad tackle away from being sent off.
[13] As a result of his behaviour in a league match against Kerry on Sunday 15 February, where he was seen to grab Paul Galvin in the groin area, he was banned for eight weeks.
[14][15][16][17] McMenamin took over as Fermanagh senior manager in August 2019, having previously spent two years serving in the background.