[5] The Indians finished the season in first place in the six–team final league standings with a 60–39 record, playing under manager Bobby Hipps.
[6][7][8] In 1939, the Lenoir Indians continued play, becoming members of the six–team Class D level Tar Heel League.
[9] The Indians placed 2nd in the standings and finished the season with 61–46 record, playing under managers Lefty Guise and Clarence Roper.
[10][13][12] In 1946, the Lenoir "Red Sox" became charter members of the four–team Class D level Blue Ridge League during the season.
The Galax Leafs, Mount Airy Graniteers and Radford Rockets and Salem Friends began 1946 league play, which commenced on May 1, 1946.
After compiling a 51–27 record while based in Lenoir, the Salem/Lenoir team placed first in the final league standings, playing the season under managers Vernon Mackey and Noel Casbier.
The Forest City Owls, Hendersonville Skylarks, Lincolnton Cardinals, Marion Marauders, Morganton Aggies, Newton-Conover Twins and Shelby Farmers teams joined Lenoir as charter members.
[23][10] Beginning Western Carolina League play on April 30, 1948, the Lenoir Red Sox placed seventh in the regular season final standings.
[24] With a record of 49–61, playing under managers Jack McLain and Claude Jonnard, Lenoir finished 20.0 games behind the first place Lincolnton Cardinals in the Western Carolina League regular season standings.
The Red Sox ended the season with a record of 57–50 under returning manager Claude Jonnard, finishing 14.5 games behind the first place Newton-Conover Twins.
Lenoir finished 0.5 game behind the first place Newton-Conover Twins (69–41) in the final regular standings, with .001 separating the teams.
In the era, the ballpark was reportedly located behind the high school at 521 West College Avenue, Lenoir, North Carolina.