[8][9][10][11][12] In 2011 May was a member of the NNSW Waratahs team that won the Australian Netball League title.
[18][19][20][21] In 2015 she played in her first Netball Superleague grand final, but finished on losing team as Mavericks lost 56–39 to Surrey Storm.
[2][20][21][24] May helped Wasps win two successive Netball Superleague titles and played in two further grand finals in 2017 and 2018.
[2][24] She was subsequently a member of the Lightning team that won the 2019 British Fast5 Netball All-Stars Championship.
In her penultimate game with Loughborough Lightning, she was the POM and after winning the grand final with them on Sunday 27 June 2021, she retired.