Wynter played Kate Warner and appeared in all 24 episodes plus the third-season premiere, and she provided her voice for 24: The Game.

In 2009, Sarah appeared in "Unnatural Love", an episode of the second season of Flight of the Conchords as "Keitha", the Australian girlfriend of Jemaine.

In 2013 she played the role of Whitney Robshaw in "Protest Too Much"[6] the 17th episode of the third season of the CBS police procedural drama Blue Bloods.

[7] She guest starred in the episode "Identity Crisis" in the first season of Person of Interest, and appeared in Californication.

Wynter appeared in The 6th Day alongside Arnold Schwarzenegger and Lost Souls with Winona Ryder as well as numerous independent movies such as Shooting Livien.