Scene of the Crime follows private detective Jack Herriman as he is hired to track down a missing person in and around San Francisco.

Later, Jack sneaks outside and rifles though the house recycling bin, finding a phone message from Maggie and a contact number that leads to a motel upstate.

Herriman tries to fight the man but is taken by surprise and winded, Knut then manages to scare the guy off with his camera flash.

From pictures his Uncle Knut took several years before, Jack discovers that Virgil was the leader of yet another compound similar to Luna House, and that it burned down.

Knut further finds a photograph featuring a young Maggie, her sister Jordan, and their mother standing before a dead body.

She also seems to harbor hatred towards Virgil, claiming that he ruined her life, and reveals, to Jack's horror, that half of her face is scarred from the burns.

Maggie's mother sees the photograph of herself standing with her daughters before her dead husband, which had been put on display in Knut's public gallery.

Jacks investigation continues, and he finds further secrets, and discovers that the Jordans did not reveal all the details of their family problems to him.