QuESt uses flexible flows throughout the mixtape and his lyrics show his emotions in rhymes about daydreams and real-life issues, such as having a friend becoming paralyzed after being shot.

[3] Searching Sylvan received unanimous critical acclaim upon its release, praising the compositions, and lyrics of the mixtape.

The Huffington Post named QuESt on their 11 Artists You Need To Know For The Rest Of 2014 list, with The Huffington Post stating "QuESt is about to prove himself one of the most promising storytellers in hip-hop" and that Searching Sylvan was not "just one of the best mixtapes or hip-hop releases this year ... [it] is one of the best albums all year".

[6] The Source says that Searching Sylvan has "incredible production, which is only matched and surpassed by QuESt’s versatile flows".

Concerning the content of the mixtape, The Source states that the project is "as high-quality as you can manage" and has "a surprising level of replay value".