He was named to one of the National Soccer Coaches Association of America All-South Region teams in all of his seasons with Duke.
[5][better source needed] After college, Ibeagha forgoed a homegrown contract with the Houston Dynamo and instead signed with Danish side AC Horsens.
[10] He struggled to find game time, so Ibeagha was sent to Houston's USL affiliate club Rio Grande Valley FC.
[11] Ibeagha made his debut for Rayo OKC on July 23 in a 1–0 defeat to Puerto Rico FC.
[13] Ibeagha and San Antonio recorded the second longest shutout streak in USL history between April 28 to June 17 when they went 672 minutes without conceding a goal.
[14] Ibeagha helped San Antonio finish second in the Western Conference by anchoring defense that led the league with 15 clean sheets and conceded a league-low 24 goals in 2017.
[14] Ibeagha signed with Major League Soccer side New York City FC on February 27, 2018, after training with the team during pre-season.
[15] He made his MLS debut in NYCFC's first game of the 2018 season, coming on as a sub in a 2–0 win against Sporting Kansas City.
[16] After not appearing in the first five games of the 2019 season, Ibeagha started against the Montreal Impact and helped NYCFC keep a clean sheet and earn a 0–0 draw.
[18] On August 6, 2021, Ibeagha was acquired by Los Angeles FC from NYCFC in exchange for $150,000 in General Allocation Money.