Following Punk's departure, Cabana and Steel teamed together one other time as the Second City Saints, when they competed in a losing effort against Jimmy Rave and Sal Rinauro of The Embassy.
At Retribution: Round Robin Challenge II, Punk introduced his on-screen girlfriend Lucy Fer as the trio's newest valet.
The feud continued the following night at War of the Wire where Prophecy leader Christopher Daniels refused to provide any information on Lucy's disappearance which led to Punk attacking him.
At Final Battle, Second City Saints attacked Prophecy and threatened to kill Allison Danger if Punk was not provided any information about Lucy's disappearance.
The following month, at Round Robin Challenge III, Second City Saints lost the titles to Maff and Whitmer in the first match of a round-robin series.
Following the event, Second City Saints continued their feud with The Prophecy as Whitmer and Maff defeated Steel and Cabana in a falls count anywhere match at Reborn: Completion.
During the first night of Death Before Dishonor II, Punk and Cabana successfully defended the Tag Team Championship against Briscoe Brothers in a two out of three falls match.
On the second night of the event, Cabana unsuccessfully challenged Samoa Joe for the ROH World Championship while Punk and Steel defeated Prophecy in an Unsanctioned Chicago Street Fight.
Cabana and Punk remained signed and briefly reunited the Saints at the final OVW show promoted under the WWE developmental banner.
Both Cabana and Steel were sitting front row in support of Punk who was facing John Cena for the WWE Championship in the main event.