The song was written and performed by the members of New Hollow, and was produced by Michael J. Clouse and Joe Viers.

It initially debuted on Hot AC radio in the United States as an independent release on Monkee Hollow Records.

[1] In December 2013, "She Ain't You" was voted the "Breakthrough Song Of 2013" by The Pulse (Sirius XM), beating out "Let Her Go" by Passenger (singer), "Best Day of My Life" by American Authors and "Say Something" by A Great Big World.

The accompanying music video was directed by Tim Kirkman and features the band performing in an indoor, dark setting.

It was originally recorded and mixed at Sonic Lounge Studios in Grove City, Ohio by Michael J. Clouse and Joe Viers in 2012.