He attended Abraham Lincoln High School in Brooklyn, New York, where he played basketball[1] and football for the Honest Abes.

[2] Following the conclusion of his senior season, Youngelman was honored with the Morris Kaufman Memorial Trophy, presented to the Lincoln player for character, leadership, sportsmanship, and ability.

[4] The 6'3" Youngelmen was accorded All-City and All-Brooklyn honors in both football and basketball at the end of his high school career.

Moving to the varsity in 1951, Youngelman made his mark as a stout defender on the line during fall practice, shutting down his offensive teammates again and again.

[6] With the sophomore Youngelman gaining a starting role, Alabama finished with a record of 5–6 in 1951 — buried in 8th place in the 12 team Southeastern Conference (SEC).