After a line-up change (the departure of Jeff and Luke and the addition of Danny and Ryan), much touring, and label negotiations, they recorded and released the Small Towns Burn a Little Slower EP in 2004 on Rise Records.
On July 26, 2005, they released their first album, Mortality as Home Entertainment, on Triple Crown Records.
On November 6, 2007, the band announced on their MySpace page that they will be breaking up as of February 2008.
They cited school, marriage and burnout brought on by the music industry as the reasons.
The band released their final album, So Begins the Test of a Man (Dead Letter Records) at their farewell concert.