[4] The definition has been expanded to refer to a social graph of all Internet users.
[5] Several issues have come forward regarding the existing implementation of the social graph owned by Facebook.
Google has attempted to offer a solution to this problem by creating the Social Graph API, released in January 2008,[8] which allows websites to draw publicly available information about a person to form a portable identity of the individual, in order to represent a user's online identity.
Both companies monetise collected data sets through direct marketing and social commerce.
[12] Facebook's Graph API allows websites to draw information about more objects than simply people, including photos, events, and pages, and their relationships between each other.