After being recommended by her boss, Paul, Amber receives an all-expenses-paid trip to Italy to participate in Tuscan Grove's special management program, as well as an opportunity to meet the company's charismatic founder and CEO, Nick Martucci.

Despite the rustic images shown online, the accommodations consist of a company-owned motel, and members of the program - Deb, Susie, Jen, Dana, and Fran - are told they cannot leave the property without permission.

At the end of the day, Nick invites her to a party the following night, and cautions her not to tell the rest of the group what has happened, to avoid accusations of favoritism.

Susie is not at the session the following day, and Jen soon excuses herself, leading Amber to share her suspicions that something is not right on the trip with fellow manager Dana.

They go into the villa to attempt to hide, but discover an orgy happening inside, attended by Nick, members of his family, Liz Bence, and attendees of Ricky's party, all filmed by Craig.

The party is interrupted as the pack of boars stampede into the house, sending the guests scattering and allowing Amber to call the police.

It was announced in May 2021 that Jeff Baena and his Horse Girl co-writer and star Alison Brie were reuniting for Spin Me Round.

Aubrey Plaza returned to act in the film, having not had a role in Horse Girl, with Alessandro Nivola, Molly Shannon and Lil Rel Howery also announced in the cast.

[5] Baena said that "the film is rooted in the expectation versus reality trope", which forms the basis for the main plot as well as other elements.

As well as contributing to the theme of subverting expectations, Baena wanted to write a complicated character for Plaza to play as neither simply villain or victim.

The website's critics consensus reads, "If it never quite lives up to its potential, Spin Me Round remains a dizzily diverting comedy elevated by Alison Brie and Aubrey Plaza's performances.