As of 2017, it was one of the largest Catholic parishes in the United States, with over 10,500 registered families and more than 12,000 weekly attendees.
[1][2] In 2017 St. Matthew's had 35,599 registered members, making up 13.7 percent of the entire population of the Diocese of Charlotte.
[3] St. Matthew's clergy and staff reportedly observed ministerial methods and management strategies from Protestant evangelical megachurches, including Saddleback Church.
[5] Until 2023, when it was overtaken by St. Charles Borromeo in Visalia, St Matthew's was the largest Catholic parish church in the United States.
Robert Yurgel, a priest at St. Matthew's, sexually abused a fourteen-year-old altar boy.