In 1926, Monsignor William Barry and five Adrian Dominican Sisters remodeled five polo stables that Carl G. Fisher had donated to the parish into five classrooms and a cafeteria.

A $75,000 building permit was issued on May 31, 1930, for St. Patrick Catholic Elementary and High School—the first of three units of the two-story school building, completed in 1932, opened in September.

Accreditation in the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools became a reality in 1933, along with the acceptance by Florida.

The school continues to provide education from Kindergarten to 8th grade.

In 1988, it was named a "National School of Excellence" by the United States Department of Education.