The main building, off Dogwood Lane, can be found on "The Horseshoe."

"The Horseshoe" is a looping driveway that surrounds Saints' Square, a memorial-square and common meeting place on the school's campus.

[16] St. Paul's also has a long-standing athletic rivalry with UMS-Wright, another local private high school that is just 2.2 miles away down Old Shell Road.

In football, the two teams meet every year in the "Battle of Old Shell Road.

"[17] St. Paul's has been coined as being a "Pathway to the Pros"[18] by regional news media in recent years referring to the vast number of professional athletes who were local stars appearing first at SPS athletic events.