In May 1847, a committee was established to find a Presbyterian minister for the city of Auckland, and to construct a suitable church.

[1][2] The church building was constructed from locally sourced basalt and Mahurangi mudstone, from a plan by architect Walter Robertson.

[2] Governor George Grey and his family attended the church, as well as many other influential members of Auckland society.

[2][1] In contrast to many other Presbyterian congregations who did not use musical instruments, an organ was also erected inside the church.

[4] Refurbishment work on the church began in April 2001, which included the removal of the louvres with stained glass.