In 1883 this building was sold,[3] and the congregation moved to the present site (feued from the Fettes Trust), at first erecting a hall, while conducting a competition for the new church, which was won by Robert Rowand Anderson in 1885.

In 1894 the Vestry voted to accept a generous offer from the distinguished artist William Hole (a member of the congregation) to create a complete painted decoration scheme, in his spare time and at no cost.

[4] In 1898 alterations were made to the chancel, in accordance with a scheme designed by Sir John James Burnet, including a gilded triptych above the altar with paintings by William Hole.

[7] In 1923 a baptistery, also designed by Sir John James Burnet, was added at the west end of the south aisle [7] and now became the way for the congregation to enter the church, through a traceried screen.

[17] The church occupies a narrow site with the east end facing Inverleith Row: It contains a chancel, a three-bay nave with south aisle, and a short tower.

The chancel decoration, including the altar, choir stalls, and paving, is by John James Burnet,[8] with windows depicting the Good Samaritan by Henry Payne of Amberley, described as "two lights with intricate, graceful drawing.

"[19] The baptistery at the west end contains a marble font by Charles d'Orville Pilkington Jackson and windows by Douglas Strachan.