Her debut performance as skip of team Newfoundland and Labrador at the 2004 Canadian Junior Curling Championships was somewhat successful, the rink finished with an 8–4 record, just missing the playoffs.

Her team of Steph Guzzwell, Sarah Paul and Julie Devereaux finished the round robin in first place with an 11–1 record.

Curtis defeated Manitoba's Calleen Neufeld 7–6 in the final to win the Canadian Junior championship.

[6] This marked the first time a team from Newfoundland and Labrador won a women's Canadian Junior championship.

Curtis would go on to win the 2017 Newfoundland and Labrador Scotties Tournament of Hearts, defeating Shelley Hardy in a playoff after a 3-1 round robin record.

At the 2018 Newfoundland and Labrador Scotties Tournament of Hearts, Curtis finished the round robin with a 5–1 record, but won all of her playoff games, including beating the previously undefeated Heather Strong team twice.

At the 2018 Scotties Tournament of Hearts, Curtis led her province to a 4–3 record in group play, but lost to Ontario in a tiebreaker to move on to the championship pool.

[9] At the 2023 Newfoundland and Labrador Scotties Tournament of Hearts, Team Curtis finished 3–1 through the round robin, tied for first place with the Heather Strong rink.

[11] There, they finished with a 2–6 record, earning victories over the Yukon's Hailey Birnie and Wild Card #3's Meghan Walter.

[13] On tour, the team only qualified in one of their three events, the Rick Rowsell Classic, where they lost the final to the Brooke Godsland rink.