[1][2][3] In October 1931, Fay gained national media attention after scoring two touchdowns in Michigan's 21–0 win over Princeton in the first meeting between the two schools in 50 years.

The United Press report on the game noted: "Stanley Fay, hard-running 175-pound halfback from Detroit, was the hero of Michigan's triumph scoring the first touchdown on a 50-yard run from a fake placement kick in the second period and clinching the contest with a seven yard dash around end for a second score in the final period.

"[7] Fay's rushing and scoring was one of the leading offensive weapons for the undefeated national champion 1932 Michigan Wolverines football team.

[10] Fay helped lead the 1933 Michigan Wolverines football team to its second consecutive undefeated season and national championship.

"[11] In September 1943, Bennett and Fay became the subject of controversy as a result of the court martial trial of William Colman, the former commanding officer of Selfridge Air Base in suburban Detroit.

Bennett testified that a shoe shining outfit had been sent to Colman by Fay but that the gift had no connection to the transfer of Benson Ford.

In October 1945, Bennett and Fay formed a new company, called B-G-F Manufacturers' Representatives Co., with attorney Byron Geller.