[7] Scott Garside of the Daily Record wrote in an August 1976 review, "Their smooth, rich vocals and harmonies are unbeatable.

However, when the instrumentation becomes prominent, the Starlnnd [sic] Vocal Band sounds like an average folk quartet.

"[9] In another contemporary review, Joan Baez of The Daily Utah Chronicle wrote, "This album is one of the gratifying surprises of the year so far.

[...] Highlights are 'Boulder to Birmingham,' 'California Day,' 'Baby, You Look Good to Me Tonight' and a gorgeous accapella [sic] version of Paul Simon's 'American Tune.'

and "As debut records go this isn't too bad, but those just looking for their finest moments should check their greatest-hits compilation.