The club existed from 1894 until 1968, after which Stevenage Athletic were established.
[1] They were renamed Stevenage Wanderers the following year, before merging with a club named Rovers, at which point the club reverted to their original name.
[1] They joined the Herts County League in 1899 but left after a single season.
[3] They moved to Broadhall Way in 1961, and in 1963 they joined Division One of the Southern League.
A new club, Stevenage Athletic, was formed in their place.