[5] In 2004, they changed to their present name and entered the Wessex Football League Division Three.

The Reserve side was also highly successful in the same season by taking the Wessex Combination League title.

In the 2010–11 campaign they reached the final of the Basingstoke Senior Cup losing to Thatcham Town 4–1.

The club then went on to win the same cup in 2013–14 beating local rivals AFC Aldermaston 3-2 (aet) in the final.

In September 2014, the club recorded probably the best result of its modern history, defeating Conference South Basingstoke Town on penalties in the Hampshire FA Senior Cup at The Camrose after a 2–2 draw in 90 minutes.

The club had its best run in the FA Vase in season 2015-16 reaching the 3rd round proper before eventually being knocked out 4–2 after a replay and extra-time against Newport (IoW) from the Wessex Premier Division.

They have also reached the final of the North Hants Senior Cup in the last two seasons: losing out 3–1 to local rivals Whitchurch United in 2016–17, again at The Camrose, and then 5–4 on penalties to Andover New Street in 2017–18 at Longmeadow after a 3–3 draw in normal time.

In 2020-21 Tadley had a change in Secretary, after many years Dean Newton step down.

The club would like to place on record are thanks for the work and time put in by Dean.

Joe Lawler & Ben Dillon was named as joint first team managers for the coming season.