She helped lead the Las Cruces squad to state championship titles in 2003 and 2005 and was named first team All-District and All-State all four years.

[4] On May 16, 2013, Lytle scored her first goal in her Sky Blue FC and National Women's Soccer League career.

This goal was scored in the 80th minute of the match, and proved to be the game winner of Sky Blue's 1–0 defeat of then first place team[5] Portland Thorns FC.

[6] In 2014, Lytle played in 7 games, starting in 5, for Sky Blue before suffering a season-ending tibia fracture and lateral meniscus tear on May 11.

[7] On December 29, 2017, Sky Blue traded Lytle and teammate Kelley O'Hara to Utah Royals FC.