In his final season with the Huskies, Peay made 22 appearances and scored six goals including a hat trick in a 4–1 victory over Santa Clara on September 3.
Peay also played in the USL Premier Development League with Ogden Outlaws, Seattle Sounders FC U-23 and North Sound SeaWolves.
Peay then went abroad to Bodo Glimt where he spent a couple months after leaving Portland Timbers at the end of 2016.
[12] Peay's option was not picked by the Monarchs at the end of the 2017 season as he was set to sign with Real Salt Lake.
On December 15, 2017, Peay signed for Real Salt Lake after they acquired his rights from Portland Timbers in exchange for a third round 2018 MLS SuperDraft pick.