The words were written as a poem in 1866 by Katherine Hankey, an English evangelist, while she was recovering from a serious illness in London.

[1] It was set to music by William Howard Doane, who was much impressed by the poem when it was recited by Major General David Russell while they were attending an international convention of the YMCA in Montreal in 1867.

Tell me the story softly, With earnest tones and grave; Remember I’m the sinner Whom Jesus came to save.

Tell me the same old story When you have cause to fear That this world’s empty glory Is costing me too dear.

Yes, and when that world’s glory Is dawning on my soul, Tell me the old, old story: Christ Jesus makes thee whole.