[1] Monèle LeStrat stars as Fawn Harriman, a recently orphaned Dannemora high school student who inherits a mysterious abandoned theatre located in Amityville, New York.

[2] Fawn Harriman, a Dannemora high school student whose parents died a year ago, inherits the Roxy, an abandoned theatre located in Amityville, New York.

Stewart saves Matt, but Wendy disappears while Fawn is captured by decomposing demons who have killed and replaced a surveyor, Jevan, Indy, and Kyle.

[4] Patrick Cooper of Bloody Disgusting lambasted The Amityville Playhouse, writing, "The film is absolutely miserable from the script to the acting.

"[5] James Luxford of Radio Times was similarly critical of the film, calling it an unoriginal "shabby shock-fest" with "stiff and awkward performances" before concluding, "Unlikely to excite even the most ardent horror fans, The Amityville Playhouse is an under-developed misfire that, if nothing else, makes you pine for scary movies of old.