The school competes in the following sports: The men's basketball team has enjoyed historical success at Apprentice.

[2] The school also fields a women's basketball team that has regularly competed nationally at their level.

[3] American football has been played at Apprentice since 1919, only breaking for two years during World War II.

The program was briefly a member of the National Club Football Association (NCFA) for the 2018 season.

[5] Led by Head Coach John Davis, the Builders won the 2018 NCFA National Championship before transitioning back to an independent varsity schedule in 2019.