In addition to weekly guest stars, the show had "a rotating stable of 'regulars'", with Jack Gilford being the only regular who was there for the program's full run.
[1] Other regulars included Joey Faye, Jack Diamond, Danny Dayton, and the Harry Mack Triplets.
[4] Guest stars on the program included Georgia Gibbs,[5] Peter Lorre,[6] and Rudy Vallee[5] The show's producers were David Levy and Rod Erickson;[7] [8] Wes McKee and William H. Brown Jr.
[10] Hooperatings of regularly scheduled sponsored TV programs in New York had The Arrow Show in the top 10 in January 1949 (eighth with a rating of 35.6)[11] and February 1949 (ninth, 32.1).
"[14] The review suggested that Gilford's performance might merit expanding his role, and it complimented the singing of Janet Blair.