The Beach at Summerly has been well received by critics, including a starred review from Library Journal.

[1] Library Journal's Stacey Hayman wrote, "This page-turner has depth of feeling and intriguing historical details that will sweep readers off their feet.

"[1] Hayman also highlighted that "the novel’s well-developed characters engage readers’ emotions while representing a variety of economic and political viewpoints.

"[1] Kirkus Reviews said the novel is "a well-researched exploration of love and redemption against the backdrop of post–World War II New England.

"[2] Star Tribune's Laurie Hertzel called The Beach at Summerly "a fascinating novel about love, class, loyalty and money.