[1]AllMusic noted The Belbury Tales "will require repeat listens in order to really appreciate the little details and the true scope of the Ghost Box sound, a fine little story book of music that slowly opens a haunted crypt of memories and prophecies.

[3] BBC Music Review called The Belbury Tales "infused with a deep vein of paranoia, a palpable fear, an attempt to reconcile the imminent unknown (evoking a reimagined or never experienced past).

"[8] Boing Boing's David Pescovitz praised The Belbury Tales citing "Jupp's freshly nostalgic forays into library music of yore filtered through his own progrock-loving, analog synth filters are enhanced with real drum and bass (and guitar) by, respectively, Jim Musgrave and Christopher Budd.

"[9] Fact reviewed The Belbury Tales "one of the most rewarding and fully realised projects in the Ghost Box catalogue – and that’s high praise indeed.

"[2] Pitchfork placed The Belbury Tales as "stranded somewhere between the abstract work of Jupp's past and the fuller sound of the live instrumentation he is applying, making this feel like his most pleasingly open-ended release so far.