Set in the 1990s world of New York City journalism, the plot follows behind-the-scenes drama amongst staff of the fictional magazine The Connector, examining themes of journalistic integrity, gender inequality and plagiarism.
Robin has tried and failed to get Conrad interested in her writing, so she's fascinated by Ethan's boldness and casual manner, and the two of them begin to form a friendship.
As Ethan makes his way through the offices, connecting with every staff member, Robin observes him with jealousy and bemusement ("I'm Watching You").
Ethan's first article, a story about his encounter with the Scrabble Prodigy, Waldo Pine, gains popularity ("Success").
Ethan's newest story is a political exposé about Willis Taylor, a man who has a copy of a videotape of the Mayor of Jersey City smoking crack with a teenager ("Wind In My Sails").
Conrad, his faith in Ethan rewarded, confides to Zachary, the magazine's attorney, that he sees retirement soon, knowing someone soon will replace him ("Now What").
At Mona's urging, Muriel uncovers evidence suggesting that Ethan may have entirely fabricated his story of the Jersey City Mayor.
As he sweeps the shredded paper off his desk, the scene transforms into a whirlwind of loose magazine pages falling to the floor ("There Never Was").