Pianist and organist Geoff Hilhorst joined the group in 2009 after the release of their breakout album Winter Hours.

Founding member Burke Barlow played guitar until 2012 when he left the group and was replaced by Clayton Linthicum.

Founding Member Lucas Goetz left the group in late 2014, after which the band went on hiatus.

The latest, Yarrow, was released on October 27, 2017 and was nominated for a Juno Award for Contemporary Roots Album of the Year category in 2019.

[3] Boldt has also released one album, Broadside Ballads, as a solo artist independently of the band, in 2015.