Rob Williams, at the time a member of The Bold Fenian Men, an Irish folk quartet, then replaced Carey on guitar and vocals.
This incarnation of the Fenians produced the albums Band of Rogues (1999), a live blend of original, traditional, and contemporary Irish tunes and Have Fun or Get Out (2001), a restating of back catalog favorites with the new lineup.
Yegin left the band in 2002 and was replaced by Dave Burnett, who played whistle, flute and saxophone on "Every Day's a Hooley", the Fenians' most eclectic offering to date.
[citation needed] The band went through several subsequent lineup changes, Casey and Pierce being the only constants, enlisting Stuart Martz on guitar/fiddle/vocals, Kenny Cosca on bass and vocals, and Nate Light- bass/vocals with no recorded output apart from a cover of Steve Earle's "Galway Girl" that was added to the 2007 Varese Sarabande/Universal release The Best of the Fenians.
The current lineup consists of Terry Casey, Rob Williams, Brendan Harkins, Tardu Yegin and drummer Bryon Holley and released in June 2013 their follow-up to "Hooley", Take Me Home.