[2][1] The column, under the banner of Kreep's Korner, reviewed classic and contemporary horror films in rhyme which were also linked to a weekly podcast on iTunes, voiced by creator O'Donnell and engineered by Eric Hoffhines.

[1] O'Donnell went on to produce and host (Dressed in steampunk garb as The Kreep) the Poetry Scream on July 30, 2010, at the Boiler Room, Port Townsend, Washington.

Kreepmas is an adaptation of the Charles Dickens’ classic A Christmas Carol with book, music, and lyrics accredited to O'Donnell's pen name The Kreep.

Steve Treacy, contributing theatre critic to the Port Townsend Leader wrote of the troupe's skills that, “Overall the group’s singing and dancing numbers, including “I’m Lamenting” and “Creepy Things,” round out one's “good to be alive” evening.” He went on to praise The Kreep, saying, “His writing, directing, acting and warbling abilities conspire to make him a quadruple threat.

Even his spoken poems, especially “Little Annie Orkle,” are sparkling (no mean feat for that musty old art form).”[7] In a “Best Local Theater of 2013” article published in the PT Leader Arts Section, "Kreepshow," a Gothic comedy cabaret conjuring some spiritual denizens of our Victorian seaport,”[8] was listed as one of the favorite locally written plays accredited to O'Donnell's pen name The Kreep.

Alice Isn't All There was re-staged and presented by St. John's Conservatory Theater on June 3, 4, 5, 17, 18, and 19, 2016 with an extended book, music, and lyrics accredited to O'Donnell's pen name The Kreep.

[17] Original songs included "Kreepy Overture", "Counting Silver", "I'm So Happy", "To Be A Zombie", "Ghost of Been There Done That", "Heed Our Warning", "Ballad of Ebenezer Scrooge", "I Hear The Bells A Ringing", and "Wish".

[27][28] In 2008, O'Donnell's The Kreep character received a Coraline handmade box numbered 46/50 assembled by the stop-motion animation team at Laika films, honoring their favorite bloggers.

An old envelope with a wax seal with inlaid black button (as used for the eyes of the witch) and a hand-typed note explained the curious gift: "We admire your dedication to The Kreep.