[5] Reviewing a performance the New South Wales Examiner said it "took the audience by surprise, and brought down a hearty and unrestrained effusion of merriment, such as the walls of the theatre have seldom witnessed.
"[6] The Sydney Herald said "the dialogue is smart, some of the original music (composed by the author) is pretty, and on the whole the piece was successful.
"[7] The Australian said "This species of entertainment is not now much in vogue, and without offending the squeamishness of any portion of our Colonial audience, we may say, that it is one to which they have not been sufficiently familiarized to be very competent critics.
But all men, women, and children, know when they are pleased, and the vast majority of such in the theatre, on Saturday night, expressed their pleasure in a manner that could not be mistaken for any thing else than the spontaneous effusion of their delight.
"[8] The Sydney Gazette said "Great credit is, notwithstanding, due to the author, for the admirable manner in which he has dramatised it.