It won Best Americana Album at the 60th Annual Grammy Awards, and International Album of the Year at the 2018 UK Americana Awards.

Additionally, "If We Were Vampires" won the Grammy for Best American Roots Song.

[21] It is Isbell's highest placement on that chart, besting Something More Than Free, which peaked at number 6 in 2015.

[21] As of December 2018, the album had sold 152,500 copies in the U.S.[22] The single "If We Were Vampires" peaked at number 29 on the Billboard Triple A Airplay chart.

[23] All tracks are written by Jason Isbell, except where notedCredits adapted from AllMusic.