Landon "Hoppy" Boyd shows two Western movies (made in 1937) in a small town.

Hoppy takes a liking to Carl and breaks his usual rule of returning stowaways to their homes.

Carl is a helpful partner on the trip and in the next town (and a skilled barber), despite his habit of wandering at night in the woods, where he converses with fairies.

He blames Binns and starts a search with the cooperation of his handsome and charming friend Arlis Faught.

Sharline climbs down to it; Binns is not in it, and she recovers the missing films and a good deal of money.

One review called The Pitcher Shower "charming" and "low-key", mentioning "gentle irony" and "whimsical characters".

It particularly praised the scene where Helen visits Hoppy and the one where the four main characters watch A Midsummer Night's Dream for the first time and talk in Shakespearean style.