"[1] Library Journal's Stacy Hayman highlighted how Williams "displays a mastery of character building while thoughtfully planting evocative details about the setting and the era's social structures.

The intricate and complex web of relationships within stated conventions are skillfully created and add depth to the narrative.

[3] Writing for Entertainment Weekly, Maureen Lee Lenker discussed Williams "knack for the obscured whisperings and yearnings of women’s lives," pointing to how she successfully writes "Miranda’s journey in both timelines with a keen eye for the wounds unique to both the first flushes of teenage love and an older, deeper, more enduring ache.

"[4] Lenker further praised Williams's strength as a historical fiction writer, saying she has a "particular gift as a writer [for] peeling back the pages of history to breathe life into the interior lives of women [...] But Williams also never falls into the trap of nostalgia, always taking care to draw back the curtain on this sparkling world to show the rottenness at its core.

"[4] Booklist's Nicole Foti wrote that Williams's "writing is precise and descriptive, and reading The Summer Wives is like watching a film, complete with love and drama to be envied, bemoaned, and enjoyed.