The West Indians bring out the inherent racism in a number of the white Australian travellers though Vicky becomes rather attached to Lance Olumide.
Helen Frizell in The Australian Women's Weekly was in no doubt about her feelings for the book: "'Dymphna Cusack, in beautifully written prose, shows how bigotry and unkindness will eventually damp down the fires of their love and ambitions, so that in the end even the hearths of their hearts will be cold.
Dymphna Cusack's thoughtfulness, narrative power, and sincerity make The Sun in Exile her best book to date.
[2] Victor Valentine, a reviewer in The Argus, was impressed with the writing: "Although the characters indulge in intermittent tambourine banging it does not matter because the tale is told in the first person by a wonderful, unforgettable spinster writer of 60, named Miss Alexandra Pendlebury.
Miss Pendlebury, rich, much travelled, gently snobbish, both about people and culture, selfish, lonely, and superfluous, is a superb touching portrait.