Founded in New York City in 1981, the band has released nine studio albums, primarily through Moon Ska Records.

[4] One of the original second-wave ska bands, the early Toasters lineup included other employees of the Forbidden Planet store.

[6][13] While the band's lineup has seen many changes, regular contributors included Coolie Ranx (vocals), Matt Malles (bass), Dave Barry (keyboards), Johnnathan McCain (drums), Freddie Reiter (saxophone), Brian Sledge (trumpet), and both Rick "Chunk" Faulkner and Erick "E-Man" Storckman on trombone.

[15] The Toasters experienced a small degree of commercial success in the late 1990s due to the popularity of third wave ska in North America.

[5] Their song "Don't Let The Bastards Grind You Down" appeared in the pilot episode of the animated series Mission Hill.

[5] The Toasters have recorded background music for many TV commercials, including for America Online and Coca-Cola.

[22] In 1998 the Toasters were part of the 'Ska Against Racism' tour, along with the Blue Meanies, Five Iron Frenzy, and Less Than Jake.