In 2019, the team broke ground on Brave Sporting Complex, its permanent club headquarters and training facilities.

The team would win the PDL Southeast Division title in their first ever season, going into the semifinals of the South conference playoffs losing 2–1 to Midland/Odessa Sockers.

The Villages SC would return to action in 2021, winning the USL 2 Southeast Division Title, defeating East Atlanta FC in the conference quarterfinal 2–1 before losing to Tormenta 2 4–2 in the semifinal.

In 2022, the club would return again to the US Open Cup, winning their first round match 6–0 against Orlando Wolves before losing to USL Championship side Tampa Bay Rowdies 6–0.

The 2023 season would see the Buffalo return to the top of the Southeast Division, winning the title and qualifying for the southern conference playoffs.

Following the club’s rebrand, they earned qualification to the US Open Cup where they drew NISA side Savannah Clovers in the first round, losing 2–0.

In 2023, the club announced its intentions to field a United Premier Soccer League team in the Florida division starting in 2024.