Productions were performed at different locations within Arlington, until finally in 1981 an older church on Division Street was bought and was remodeled.

1990 began for Theatre Arlington with the sale of the Division Street Theater.

Theatre Arlington then moved on from its old establishment to its new beginning on Main Street in the center of downtown in 1991.

On New Year's Eve 1991, the new theater which had 199-seats opened with a successful play named "Pump Boys and Dinettes".

And even more In August 2000, Theatre Arlington was donated a 7,500-square-foot (700 m2) building, across the street from it, to use for the expansion of their educational programs.