"Then What" peaked at number 33 on the ARIA Charts and was certified platinum.

Illy told Ben & Liam on Triple J "You notice people come around that weren't there before.

When the times are good, they're there, and inevitably you sort of go quiet, start working on new stuff and they're not around anymore.

"[2] At the APRA Music Awards of 2020, "Then What" was nominated for Most Performed Urban Work of the Year.

[3][4] Zanda Wilson from The Music Network said "('Then What') is cut from the same cloth as some of his biggest radio hits, with Illy's clean and energetic combination of rapping and singing underpinned by production with pop sensibilities.