The player controls the protagonist from the previous game, Jack Boyd, under new name Warren Nash, who is trying to hide from federal agents in the fictional city of Sharpwood in 1987.

This Is the Police 2 features a range of mechanics that add depth and complexity to the gameplay, providing players with a challenging and immersive experience in managing law enforcement in the town of Sharpwood.

As sheriff, players are tasked with making crucial decisions that impact the outcome of investigations, law enforcement operations, and the overall state of the town.

By managing the police force and allocating resources effectively, players must maintain law and order while dealing with a wide range of criminal activities, such as robberies, homicides, drug trafficking, and more.

Tactical decision-making plays a vital role during intense confrontations, where players must manage their limited resources and ensure the safety of their officers.