[2] According to the 1915 edition of Spalding's Official Foot Ball Guide, he was one of "the main factors in Villanova's defense.

"[2] In 1917, Reap assumed the head coaching position at his alma mater, a post he held for four seasons.

[3] In 1921, he enrolled in the law school at Dickinson College, where he also served as the line coach for the football team.

[7] Reap died in a Scranton, Pennsylvania, hospital while undergoing unspecified treatment on February 9, 1935, at the age of 40.

[7] His brother and former Villanova teammate, Jim Reap, served as a Lackawanna County sheriff.