Conley joined the PGA Tour in 1993, earning his card through qualifying school.

In 1994 he played on the Nationwide Tour full-time and recorded a runner up finish but only made 7 of 21 cuts.

He continued to play on the Nationwide Tour and won the Nike Gateway Classic in 1996 in a playoff.

[1] He returned to the PGA Tour in 1998, earning his card through qualifying school.

He finished 83rd on the money list in his rookie year on Tour, missing only one cut in 13 events.