Tammy, Jocelyn, Zeke, and Jimmy Jr. taunt Tina about the box, until Louise has them all use the Ouija board to communicate with Jeff.
Louise and Gene resolve to get back at Tammy by scaring her on Halloween night when the older kids plan to enter a mausoleum in the nearby cemetery.
Tina surprises them by joining the group and they head into the mausoleum, which immediately shuts and traps them inside in complete darkness.
The kids light a candle and are frightened to find a message written in blood on the mausoleum walls, allegedly from Jeff, condemning them all to Hell.
Tina calms everyone down by revealing that she pretended the mausoleum door was locked and wrote the message before they arrived in ketchup to scare them, having realized long ago that Jeff was not real.
"[2] Robert Ham of Paste gave the episode an 8.7 out of 10, saying "The plot was decidedly thin, but it was really its own vessel to move young Tina one step forward toward maturity.