Scicluna began his professional career in 1998 with Indiana Blast in the USISL Pro League.
[2] In 2004, he signed with newly formed Windsor Border Stars of the Canadian Professional Soccer League.
[citation needed] He helped Windsor capture the Open Canada Cup, and qualify for the postseason.
[3] In 2015, he signed with Waza Flo of the Major Arena Soccer League, an organization founded by his brothers.
In 2002, Madonna University hired the services of Scicluna to coach the men's soccer team.