The smaller theatre was extensively reconstructed in 1909, again by Frank Matcham, and re-opened in July 1910 as the Tivoli.

On 10 July 2009, the owner of the Tivoli Theatre decided to sell the property to Mr Brian Hendry.

[4] On 19 April 2012, it was announced that the Theatre had been made wind and watertight and that its frontage had been brought back to its former glory.

The next phase of the restoration was set to bring the interior up to 21st century standards, including a 450-seat auditorium, a cafe and a gallery.

Joseph Purdy Productions became the first UK touring pantomime to visit the Tivoli in July 2018 with Rapunzel.